Masthead graphic based on a painting by Gudrun Thriemer.

Sunday, March 04, 2007

"MINUSTAH missions cause hunger," March 5, 2007.

This year, International Women's Day comes as World Report is investigating the UN's new version of peacekeeping.

I considered doing a story about peacekeepers in Africa where countries continue to add their signatures to the African Protocol on the Rights of Women at the same time that more than 200 cases of sexual abuse by United Nations peacekeepers are under investigation in the Democratic Republic of Congo alone.

But that story's not quite ripe yet, and the women who have offered their comments and suggestions about World Report over the years have made at least one point clear. They prefer stories that feature actual human beings even if they are living a crisis over dry statistics and statements by public relations specialists who only make excuses for government policy.

One of this week's "finds" for me was a weblog called "Dying in Haiti" by an American doctor who works in a Cite Soleil clinic. So I decided to stick with Haiti for another week.

Last week, we heard about several recent incidents in Cite Soleil described as massacres.

Haiti may be the only country where the UN has a peace keeping mission which has taken on heavily armed gangs.

For its part, the UN reports fewer casualties than people on the ground do. The UN also denies firing on civilians or firing from helicopters.

In their Feb 15 press release announcing UNSC Resolution 1743 which extends the MINUSTAH mission in Haiti, David Wimhurst a spokesman for the UN refers to a quote "particularly virulent misinformation campaign" directed against MINUSTAH by pro-Aristide forces.

The Haiti Information Project accuses MINUSTAH of "utter disregard...for civilian causualties" and alleges that on both July 6, 2005 and December 22, 2006, "not a single medical unit accompanied the UN forces" (HIP Feb 1 07).

World Report has contacted MINUSTAH headquarters with questions about the lack of medical support. I'll let you know what they say.

Wimhurst claims quote "that MINUSTAH made strenuous efforts to investigate every genuine allegation that its troop had killed or injured a civilian." Maybe there will be something about the issue of medical accompaniment.

Meanwhile, John Carroll is a medical doctor from Peoria, Illinois now working in Cite Soleil.

Dr Carroll doesn't comment on the total numbers of casualties, on whether or not there is firing from UN helicopters, or on whether the deaths are caused by UN peacekeepers or by gangs. He expresses no political preference for Aristide or anyone else.

But he and his doctor's eyes take a walk through Cite Soleil, and we can see something of what it's like to live there while MINUSTAH, the UN mission in Haiti keeps the peace.

Carroll sees the horrific shooting war where quote "hundreds of thousands of people are trapped inside this slum paying homage to the gangs and their soldiers or are running from the bullets from the MINUSTAH tanks and automatic weapons. However, the violence hurts the people of Soleil in so many other ways than just death and injury from bullets....

"On February 7 [he writes] I looked over the balcony rail from the second floor of our clinic in Cite Soleil. Five UN (MINUSTAH) tanks were patrolling the streets directly below us and passing by slowly in single file. Their guns were not aimed at the clinic like usual as I took their picture. A TV cameraman from Channel 4 in London took a long video of them as they passed and waved.

"Despite the friendly waves, two days later, in the early morning hours, 700 UN forces, mainly Brazilian, entered the slum and had a fierce gun battle with a gang in the Boston region of Cite Soleil. The shooting lasted for hours. All the main roads into the Soleil were blocked by tanks. People were allowed out on foot and were not allowed to return until late afternoon when the shooting had stopped....

"The gangs in Soleil shot thousands of rounds of ammunition at the UN. The gangs have M-14's, 9 mm weapons, 38's, American-style machine guns, and hand grenades. I have seen these weapons up close and personal and they appear even more menacing in the hands of shirtless, 19-year-old young men, who are hungry and on the run-being hunted by UN forces. The UN tanks have 50 mm machine guns and on Friday they had a remote control airplane circling Soleil....

"Father Tom Hagan has a program here in Haiti called Hands Together. Father Tom has eight schools in Soleil, a medical clinic, and feeds 10,000 children each day in this massive slum....

"[On Friday]..., Father walked down the middle of the main road in Soleil, saying the rosary, and opened his ...feeding center at Soleil 24. There was no traffic except UN tanks. Forty UN tanks were inside and outside of Soleil at that point.

"Father's schools were closed because his teachers could not get in the slum. And with the shooting, parents were afraid to send their kids to school. [Dr Carroll comments that] It says quite a bit when Haitian parents are too frightened to send their kids to school because that means no education and probably very little food that day for their children.

"People delivering food into Soleil were not allowed in on February 7, and so the women who sell in the main market had nothing to sell even if they could have during the barrage of bullets. This weekend, there has been very little food for hundreds of thousands of people.

"In an area of Soleil called the Wharf, The Daughters of Charity have six sisters who do incredible work. They have a medical clinic that sees several hundred children a day for acute medical problems. They also have a pediatric vaccination program and a malnutrition program for 50 very malnourished babies. They provide two hot meals for these babies Monday through Friday. While the babies are napping, their mothers participate in a well-organized sewing program, designed to teach them a skill.

"The sisters also have a school in Soleil near the clinic that has 600 students. Each day the sisters provide 1,200 hot meals for the kids in their schools and programs.

"None of this happened on Friday. The medical clinic was closed. The school was closed. The malnutrition program was closed. Nobody got fed. And most of these people had no food in their homes this weekend either.

"One of the sisters had a scheduled vacation to her home country in South America and had to walk out of the slum with her suitcase in her hand amid the gun fire. She was picked up outside the slum by a driver who took her to the airport.

"A friend of ours who runs an orphanage four miles from Soleil was besieged by twenty women from Soleil who had snuck out of the slum with their babies asking her to take their kids, feed them, clean them, and put them up for adoption. Our friend had to deny their requests because she already has over 100 children in the orphanage and absolutely no where to put these kids or give them adequate care. They all had to return to Soleil....

"Today, Sunday, Father Tom picked me up and we went to Soleil in his jeep. He says mass on Sunday mornings at Saint Ann's which is in the back part of Soleil called Soleil 17....

"After Mass, ... a lady approached and asked me if I would examine her daughter.

"I turned around and walked back with her and stepped into her shack. Lying on a bed was her 19 year old daughter who was shot in the back, abdomen, and left arm by MINUSTAH on December 27 as she sat outside her shanty. She was hospitalized at St. Catherine's, a small hospital in Soleil, where she underwent abdominal surgery and was hospitalized for 8 days.

She was lying on a small bed with perspiration covering her forehead in this hellhole. She complained of abdominal pain and said she is not able to eat. Her surgical dressing is still in place and she said she has an appointment tomorrow at St. Catherine's.

Her 3 month old baby girl was lying at her feet. The baby had not had milk in four days because she says she has no breast milk and they have no powdered milk in the one room shack which serves as their home. I saw the empty tin can of Alaska powdered milk next to her bed. They have been giving the baby some boiled water and mashed up cookies in water. The baby seemed fairly content under the circumstances.

I told the 19 year old mom and her mother that I would find the baby some powdered milk and bring it to them....

"Father and I continued on and arrived in the Boston section of Cite Soleil and then crossed over to another district of Soleil called Beleco. I went over and talked to a Beleco gang of soldiers. They immediately asked me what I was going to do for them. They were armed and are the soldiers of the escaped gang leader Evans who is hiding in the slum. They said they are hungry also.

People are loyal to Evans. Even though he kills and extorts money, he still feeds thousands of people. He is hidden among them now and no one will say where he is. His name isn't even mentioned. However, the people of the slum fear him and his soldiers less than they do MINUSTAH which shoot to kill from their big white tanks that pass through their neighborhoods.

While I was talking to the soldiers of Evans' gang, a 40 year old lady with a low voice asked me if I would check her mother, who was very sick. As I was walking to her shack in the maze that never seems to end in Soleil, I stumbled onto a lady selling te (earth) which are circular 5 inch diameter pies made of mud with butter and salt mixed in. They are baked in the sun. They are made right in the slum to stem people's hunger. They offered me one which I declined. A pretty 20 year old girl took a big bite of one of these toxic patties, chewed it up and swallowed it while she smiled at me.

I followed the lady with the sick mother and arrived at their shack about 30 yards from the road. Her 62 year old mother lay on the floor next to a bed lying on her right side. She was covered with flies and groaning softly. Her family obviously could not give her any significant care. They said she was not eating and could not stand.

When I examined her on the floor, she was lethargic and had a hard mass in her abdomen that seemed to be originating from her liver. The family showed me some worthless medication she was taking.

The family carried her to Father Tom's vehicle and we loaded her in back. As we left Soleil, the gang members from Boston waved and smiled as they walked down the road. We took her to a home for dying and abandoned adults run by the Missionaries of Charity.... The Sisters graciously accepted her and her death will be easier now than it would have been on her floor in Soleil."

Digg This

Recommend this Post

Sphere: Related Content